Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations GregLocock on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

PhD in Structural Engineering 3

Status
Not open for further replies.

labeattie

Structural
Aug 27, 2014
43
Hi All,

I am a recent MS (non-thesis) graduate in civil/structural engineering. My masters classes were very structurally specialized and that is where my interests lie. I am currently working as an EIT at a smaller firm, but will likely have to move in 4 yrs when my spouse completes her education. I think there is a good chance that I would like to pursue a PhD in structural engineering at a fairly prestigious university (no specific one chosen) after that move, but I am concerned about limiting my job opportunities. My primary motivation for undertaking the degree is interest in the subject material. I found myself very interested in structural mechanics and the math, theory, and computer procedures behind different kinds of structural analysis, and would like to learn more in the area. My professors all mostly thought it would be a great idea for me to get my PhD, but I'm not sure that academia is my end goal. At the bridge engineering firm for which I interned throughout school, there were two PhD's high up in the structural staff, but I know that is not necessarily typical. I would like to retain the flexibility of working mostly anywhere that is a fairly large city in the US, as my location options will most likely be limited to where my spouse can work as well. The money lost in the years of study is unappealing to me, but obviously not a deal-breaker. As far a jobs I would be interested in after graduating go, bridge engineering, building engineering, and more computer-based jobs such as working for a software company are all possibilities. With these goals and concerns, do you guys think the PhD is a good idea, or will it be too difficult to find a good-paying job in the US region of my choosing? Also note that I expect to have a PE and probably not an SE license at the time in question.

-labeattie
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

I see some recommend getting MBA as more valuable than a PhD

That quote could only have come from someone who has an MBA (i.e. a Massive Brain Aneurysm).

Maui

 
For the record oldestguy, my last comment was not directed at you but at the source who had suggested that getting an MBA was more valuable than a Ph.D.

Maui

 
Why do all the "Professional" societies push so hard for advanced education like PHD's?
 
Easy answer. Many in the societies are university professors. If they didn't have any PhD students, no job.
 
Most profesional societies make their money from industry and their employees, so PhD's do not have much influence. In an industry where professional's earnings are based on billable hours, so it is difficult to voluteer, the subsidized academics can dominate.
 
Buggar-because the professional institutions committees are excessively dominated by academics. Also, because the current membership will be grandfathered in, there is a benefit to current membership by raising the barriers to entry, since they get some of the perceived benefit of a PhD without having to do one.

Cheers

Greg Locock


New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor