Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet
Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals
-
Congratulations waross on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
"Merging distance" in Join and Healing operations 2
- Thread starter bhopalmp
- Start date
TurbulentFluid
Mechanical
Please do? Often I do "heal" in order to get a solid, but Catia still refuses to "solidify" the part, claiming there are errors in geometry, while I can locate none. How to fix this? Is there a way to "tweak" "heal" in order not to fail?
Thanx!
Thanx!
-
2
- #4
TurbulentFluid:
The first thing that you need to do is do a connect check on all surfaces. You would need to multi-select all surfaces to be joined, and then use the "connect checker" function. (c: Connect Checker in power input, if you can't find it)
The result of this analysis will tell you the MINIMUM distance required to close. It must be under .025, and you also need to watch for surfaces that do not connect. (as in overlap) So for example, if your surfaces analyze with a max value of .007, then you would enter .007 (possibly .008) into the merging distance in the "join" command, or fix it, if you want it more accurate. If you are translating data to another CAD system, it is highly recommended - at least by me - that you work to get your merging distance as close to the minimum .001 as possible.
Secondly - sometimes it is possible that you can get a join, even when the geometry is not suitable for closing. This happens when surfaces ovelap, but they are joined by an adjacent surface. To find this condition, you would need to use the "boundary" function. (c:Boundary on power input) If there is an overlap, a green boundary will be created around the offending geometry. (it just puts a boundary on any unclosed edge, so it's a slick trick for finding it fast)
Third - and most important - "heal" is no way to design surfaces. If you just need to tweak data fast, to get it useable, it's OK - but a marginal function, at best. NEVER rely on heal to be your save-all function. It should always be used with a boulder sized grain of salt. Usually, you just need to fix the surfaces manually.
Hope that helps.
---
CAD design engineering services - Catia V4, Catia V5, and CAD Translation. Catia V5 resources - CATBlog.
The first thing that you need to do is do a connect check on all surfaces. You would need to multi-select all surfaces to be joined, and then use the "connect checker" function. (c: Connect Checker in power input, if you can't find it)
The result of this analysis will tell you the MINIMUM distance required to close. It must be under .025, and you also need to watch for surfaces that do not connect. (as in overlap) So for example, if your surfaces analyze with a max value of .007, then you would enter .007 (possibly .008) into the merging distance in the "join" command, or fix it, if you want it more accurate. If you are translating data to another CAD system, it is highly recommended - at least by me - that you work to get your merging distance as close to the minimum .001 as possible.
Secondly - sometimes it is possible that you can get a join, even when the geometry is not suitable for closing. This happens when surfaces ovelap, but they are joined by an adjacent surface. To find this condition, you would need to use the "boundary" function. (c:Boundary on power input) If there is an overlap, a green boundary will be created around the offending geometry. (it just puts a boundary on any unclosed edge, so it's a slick trick for finding it fast)
Third - and most important - "heal" is no way to design surfaces. If you just need to tweak data fast, to get it useable, it's OK - but a marginal function, at best. NEVER rely on heal to be your save-all function. It should always be used with a boulder sized grain of salt. Usually, you just need to fix the surfaces manually.
Hope that helps.
---
CAD design engineering services - Catia V4, Catia V5, and CAD Translation. Catia V5 resources - CATBlog.
- Thread starter
- #5
Just a little addition to Solid7's great post 
When importing geometry from non-solid formats like IGES, you have 2 alternatives - reconstruction of the non fitting surfaces, or healing. For non-critucal assignments, I use healing, and then re-build the solid (if needed). For importent surface modeling, re-building the surfaces might be unavoidable.
When importing geometry from non-solid formats like IGES, you have 2 alternatives - reconstruction of the non fitting surfaces, or healing. For non-critucal assignments, I use healing, and then re-build the solid (if needed). For importent surface modeling, re-building the surfaces might be unavoidable.
- Status
Similar threads
- Question
- Locked
- Question
- Locked
- Question