Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

Register Log in
  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Table Tennis Rubbers 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
PNachtwey

PNachtwey

Electrical
Oct 9, 2004
772
What would make a table tennis rubber more springy? I understand that rubber has long chains of polymers that can be compressed or stretched. I also know that there is some molecular resistance that must absorb some of the energy. How does one reduce the molecular resistance so the rubber transfers more energy to the ball instead of internal heat? Also, does anybody have examples of existing rubbers that have a low internal resistance?

I am an electrical engineer a little bit about out side my field of expertise but it seems to me that a table tennis ball hitting a paddle can be modeled as a sphere ( mass ) hitting a bunch of coiled springs. Hooke's law would apply but one must also take into account the mass of the springs and the internal damping.

Thanks


Peter Nachtwey
Delta Computer Systems
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Sort by date Sort by votes
Elastic moduli and damping vary with crosslink density in thermosetting elastomers (e.g. rubber). Crosslink density is varied by adjusting material (resin type, hardener/initiator concentration, etc.) and process conditions (e.g. temperature).
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
If you are making sanctioned paddles, you are limited to a rather thin thickness for the striking surface:
I think that you'll find that there are:
> A LOT of material choices > all of them have some compromise somewhere to achieve the totality of performance required

TTFN
faq731-376
7ofakss

Need help writing a question or understanding a reply? forum1529

Of course I can. I can do anything. I can do absolutely anything. I'm an expert!
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
There are the basic rubber properties. Also, most of the rubber has "pips" on the inside, size/spacing affect the springiness. Then there is the sponge layer, thickness and hardness. Then there is the paddle (aka blade) which has any number of factors that will affect the bounce; thickness, composition, type of wood, number of plies, composite reinforcement.

If you look at the ratings for table tennis equipment, you will be absolutely baffled at how many parameters there are. Most of them subjective, no idea how they claim to test them.

If you really want to get confused, look up "speed glue." Ignoring the context and just answering the initial question, speed glue makes table tennis rubber more springy. It has been banned for competition.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I am an club TT player. I know about the different types of rubbers one can buy. Yes, I have used speed glue too. I am looking for more of an engineering type of answer as to what makes a rubber springy.

CoryPad said:
Elastic moduli and damping vary with crosslink density in thermosetting elastomers (e.g. rubber). Crosslink density is varied by adjusting material (resin type, hardener/initiator concentration, etc.) and process conditions (e.g. temperature).
Click to expand...
Would I be correct in assuming that those polymers with fewer crosslinks would have a lower internal resistance?

If I drop a ball on a rubber the ball will only bounce up a fraction of the original height because of the coefficient of restitution. Clearly the rubber absorbs some of the impact energy. This must be due to some form of internal resistance in the rubber. Are these crosslinks responsible for the internal resistance?

Thanks






Peter Nachtwey
Delta Computer Systems
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
When discussing coefficient of restitution (CoR), a lower numbers means inelastic energy, e.g. through damping. Damping is caused by motion of the polymer chains. Crosslinking reduces the motion, reduces damping, and increases CoR.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Increasing crosslinking means the chains are covalently bonded to each other in more locations, which decreases damping. If you increase crosslinking enough, the part moves from a flexible elastomer to a stiff, brittle thermoset.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Isn't table tennis, a ping pong table which is some type of wood composite for a surface?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I don't want to go over old ground but much will depend on the relative thicknesses of the rubber cover and, where it exists, the underlying sponge layer. Increasing the crosslink density will certainly raise the resilience of the rubber, but not that dramatically once optimum cure for other key properties has been exceeded. But a thin rubber layer, however well cured, will have limited effect against the damping behaviour of the sponge. And, of course, we all have to comply with the requirements of the ITTF.

Have a look at the article Guide to Choosing Table Tennis Rubber on mega.spin.net
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
CoryPad, damping is the d term in m*x"+d*x'+k*x=F(t)
basically damping is a frictional force proportional to the velocity x'. The higher the damping the more the rubber or sponge will absorb energy and not return it to the ball. Assume the reference is the paddle. On impact the ball will compress the rubber converting all the kinetic energy into potential energy and heat. When the rubber accelerates the ball in the opposite direction some of the potential is lost again due to damping but also the some of the energy must move the sponge as well as the ball.

CoryPad said:
Increasing crosslinking means the chains are covalently bonded to each other in more locations, which decreases damping. If you increase crosslinking enough, the part moves from a flexible elastomer to a stiff, brittle thermoset.
Click to expand...
Doesn't increasing the number of cross links make it more difficult for the polymers to slide by each other. This would increase internal friction or damping.

To get maximum speed after impact one would want to reduced the damping d to as low as possible and also reduce the mass of the spring ( rubber ) so less energy is used to accelerate the rubber and more can accelerate the ball.

Reducing the d term, damping, is part of making rubbers more efficient ( faster ). My question is how does one reduce the d term at the polymer level. It seems that more cross links is not the answer. Few cross links may let the polymer chains slide by each other more easily and therefore have a lower internal resistance.
Longer cross links may also allow the polymers to move relative to each other more freely.

I said above, I am a mid level club player and an engineer.
I am aware of megaspin.net. Most of the information there is marketing hype and opinion.
I have bought many rubbers but playing with them doesn't tell me anything about how a manufacture makes one rubber "faster", springier or more efficient than another rubber.
I am looking into what rubbers would be the most efficient and how are they cross linked that makes them so special.

Thanks again for any useful information






Peter Nachtwey
Delta Computer Systems
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
To ensure we’re on the same wavelength, let’s review some rubber chemistry. Natural rubber has the highest rebound resilience and the lowest internal damping. In principle polybutadiene should match or better NR but in practice falls short and has inferior vulcanizate properties. NR is usually crosslinked with 2 -4 % elemental sulfur assisted by one or more accelerators. Elasticity is highest in the ‘gum’ state, ie with antioxidants and pigments but without fillers. The resulting hardness is 30 to 40 Shore A units but can be raised a little by a small amount of filler such as calcium carbonate. Using sulfur levels above normal can raise elasticity but at about 10 % the vulcanizate enters the ‘loggy’ phase between soft rubber and ebonite. The increase in hysteresis is caused not by the change in crosslink density but by the substantial increase in main chain modification, usually in the form of cyclic sulfides. That causes an increase in the glass transition temperature and the closer this gets to room temperature the higher the damping. I have not seen any evidence that crosslink length has any bearing on viscoelastic behaviour. Even in a well cured rubber there are relatively few crosslinks within the network – and the network is the key feature governing recovery. As far as ease of polymer chain slippage is concerned, don’t forget that leads to creep and set if the crosslink density is below optimum, thus increasing energy loss.
My company looked at compound development many years ago, but if my memory serves me there was nothing worth pursuing. Which isn’t really a surprise given the influence of pimples, surface tack, thickness, tensioning, glue etc. Hence the wide selection of rubber covers now available, including the anti-spin harder sheets and the use of synthetic elastomers such as neoprene. Sometimes I think it comes down to personal preference and a question of faith rather than science, and naturally we can’t forget the skill factor. However, good luck with your investigation
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
According to this article, speed glue is though to work by creating a trampoline effect. The solvent in the glue makes the foam layer swell and that stretches the rubber out layer, giving the trampoline effect (just like a drum with the skin pulled tightly would be more bouncy).

If this is true then it's nothing to do with cross-linking or the rubber material. You could test the theory by first stretching a rubber then gluing it in place. That would get you around the rules against speed glue as well.


Chris DeArmitt PhD
President - Phantom Plastics LLC

Trusted adviser to leading companies around the world
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

exhibitguy
  • Locked
  • Question
polybutadiene for elliptical pool table
Replies
0
Views
20
exhibitguy
exhibitguy

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top Bottom