Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations GregLocock on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

To Hire or not to Hire: That is the Problem 5

Status
Not open for further replies.

DONMARQUEZ

Chemical
Jul 7, 2006
4
Hi I hope everyone is having a nice weekend and wanted to say thanks for taking the time in reading my first post to the forums. Hopefully it isn’t going to become too long winded with human emotions and that I get my current situation and questions across. I graduated from a South Florida university in August of 2003 with a B.S. in chemical engineering and a minor in biomedical engineering with an overall G.P.A. of about a 3.4. I consider myself a first generation here in the United States because I came here with my mom when I was about two years old to Miami and we do not have any previous relatives that have lived in the states. The university I was attending was in the process of becoming ABET accredited and at the time I had the opportunity of attending two career fairs at the university campus and talked to several chemical engineers that graduated from the same school and were currently employed in large and/or well known companies such as Johnson & Johnson and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to name just a few, and they were earning within the salary range that for example Salary.com posts, although that might not be a good example.

Things did look bright until December of 2002 when we all had a sudden meeting that the chemical engineering program was going to eventually be closed and obviously not going to continue with the accreditation process. The last graduating class was in August of 2003 and I was one of the few who graduated that month. A few months ago when I talked to the only remaining professor at the university who taught chemical engineering courses said that the program was not cancelled but placed in hiatus, and that the only reason it has not been cancelled yet was because of all the paperwork and communication needed to go between the university and Tallahassee. As far as the “traditional” networking mediums with professors, students, graduate students, advisors and events like the career fair are no longer an option for me. The main reason being, like I said the only person from the program is a professor who even though he graduated from possibly the number one ranked or if not two ranked chemical engineering program/university he had no serious connections to the industry since he went straight from the classroom as a student to academia. The other professors left to pursue their goals whether in academia or in the field. Of the twelve or so students that we had, I say about ten were international students and the others moved to other states. Everyone migrated out back to their countries or to other states or what not within a year of this happening.

You name it I have tried it. Yellow pages, white pages, over three dozen online websites, government, state jobs, city jobs, local jobs, national jobs, head hunters, public career fairs held annually or bi-annually depending on the county. I’ve tried networking by getting business cards from these folks, joining a local Sunday church meeting group, and doing a little bit of work from charity organizations, among other things as well. I must have sent out over a thousand resumes that I have lost count. I’ve talked to professors and deans from four different universities and got the same response from them which was the following “if you do decide to go for a master’s do it because you love your field not because you think it will be a guarantee for a job”. I guess they could have fed me the line that everything was going to be peachy about getting a graduate degree since universities are in part a business as well. They told me that I had a good chance to get into a master’s program but that I would have to pay a good part of the expenses, which I cannot afford right now, and that my G.P.A. would probably have to be a 3.5 or higher if I decided to go as a candidate for the PhD which I do not have. Three of the four universities did tell me that with my financial situation the “ideal circumstance” would be to get my masters if I were employed by a company that has a program that pays part of the degree.

After trying all of these things basically all I have to show for in the three years that I have graduated are two very low paying technical jobs, not engineering related although science related like high school chemistry knowledge for example. The first job I had lasted for a few months until I got laid off. Half of the company which was the manufacturing side was sent to China to save costs, about a year later since this did not remedy the problem, Honeywell ended up buying the company. The second job I had was basically about a six month contract doing basically chemistry laboratory work. The very last option I took that was radically different of what I have already done in trying to get a job was going to the American Chemical Society meeting in Washington D.C. I talked to several people on what else I could do and if they could critique my resume. It has already been reviewed about eight times from four different people prior to my trip to D.C. but I wanted another perspective I guess. The summary comes down to that most likely I would have to relocate as the only viable option, but that my resume seemed that it basically had the “meat and potatoes.” I guess the small good news is that in all of this I have a little bit of job experience as well as interviewing skills and that I nailed both interviews that landed me the two jobs that I previously held, however both jobs were located in South Florida.

I guess I am very frustrated because I only know what a chemical engineer does not by my experience but what magazines and books say they do. I have never pigeon-holed myself into just doing one aspect such as research as an example. I am open to manufacturing, energy, food; paper, healthcare, biotechnology, government, oil industry etc. just to name a few. And I have sent resume to these fields among others as well. I am not looking for the golden 6 figure salary job, but I am embarrassed about being on the other side of the spectrum. I am a 29 year old single guy still living with his mom where she has two jobs because I cannot pay my own bills. I’ve even tried jobs such as Home Depot or Best Buy and not even get called for that. Hell even my best friend foots the bill when we go out to eat, and he works as a security guard. One of my friends who works at one of these similar places as an assistant manager say that for the most part they will not hire someone like me because they know that I will be looking for a job elsewhere. It is more viable to hire someone still in high school or in college that can put in several years than someone like me. Do I have leprosy? I have even tried looking into the pharmacy program, too expensive and the nursing program which seems more viable as options. In any case these are my following questions.

1. Is the only option basically moving, or do you think I have other options as far as being able to ever practice as an engineer?

My two cents on why I think I have never been called outside of Florida is because I come from an unaccredited school or possibly because since most chemical engineering jobs are located in the Northeast, Midwest and Texas for example why would a company look for someone all the way over here when they have candidates from much better schools a few miles away or at worst case scenario a state or two away. Or maybe it is something else or a combination of?

2. Is it too late to enter the field as an engineer with almost three years being out of
touch with my field?

My two cents on this is that since every year you have new graduates, basically you are competing with them, they are fresh out of school.

3. Do you know someone with a similar experience and what they did to get out of
it? Meaning how did they eventually get the engineering job?

I guess what I mean above is that do you have a similar personal experience or a friend or relative who has had trouble getting a job in the engineering field because of: The person came from an unaccredited school, location, financial troubles, not having an extended network of family or professionals because you came from poverty or consider yourself a first generation in the states. I guess to coin the phrase it is not always what you know but who you know. Or if you know someone in this situation did they do a complete overhaul in their lives and did a 180 turn by choosing a completely unrelated field?

Well I want to thank you for the time in taking to read what probably turned into a novel. Sometimes I wonder if I should have become a lawyer, an accountant, a pill dispenser also known as a pharmacist, a doctor who is just in it for the money, or a strip club owner down here in Miami. I would probably be living the “Miami lifestyle” and would be taking care of my mom instead of the other way around, although I would have to sell my soul and do something I would have not enjoyed except for maybe one of the choices.

Regards,

Juan
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Have you thought about teaching high school math, physics, or chemistry as an interim way to get on your feet? Public schools are desperate for people that can teach that sort of thing, and will often give you a alternative path to a teacher certification. This gives you a job that pays the bills with decent hours, and then you go work the masters degree.

The other option is you borrow some money, move to Houston, and go start looking here. Lots of companies looking for chemical engineers in the Houston area. And again if all else fails you can teach in the publics schools in the Houston area to get by, especially if you are bi-lingual. Do you speak Spanish? Schools are desperate for Spanish speaking teachers.

Get out of Miami. That is not where the Chem E jobs are at.

-The future's so bright I gotta wear shades!
 
SMS is right on about Miami not being the place to be for ChemE. And I second his very good suggestion about teaching. Teach for America is a fairly large organization that places college grads in teaching positions in troubled schools, maybe check them out.
 
I have had to move for EVERY job I have ever had. EVERY SINGLE ONE.



Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.
 
Get outa Dodge, dude. It's obvious that Mom can fend for herself. Move to Houston and get working before your skills get totally stale and you lose the benefit of your education! Trouble is, you should have done that at least two years ago.
 
I have had to move for EVERY job I have ever had. EVERY SINGLE ONE.

Me too, but never internationally (so far).
 
I want to personally thank you guys for reading my lengthy post and giving me ideas as well.

SMS:

Teaching definitely seems like an option. I would not mind since I have done tutoring before to several students in math and chemistry. I am bilingual, I do speak and read Spanish and English, and I guess this would be a big plus in the Houston area. The only thing I really can’t do is write in Spanish, I think I may have done that twice in my life. Moving has always been an option for me, I think the main factor for me was finding states that had a shortage of chemical engineers. I have heard that Colorado and Virginia are possibilities, but I have heard recently as Houston being one of the hot spots. New Jersey on the other hand I have heard horror stories. Thanks for the information, I’ll look into it and see what I need to do to prepare myself for the transition.

BrunoPuntzJones:

Yeah I agree that Miami is definitely not the spot to be. I guess having the couple of jobs previously made me have a false sense of security that everything would work out and that someone would eventually give me a call. It also allowed me to put the idea of moving on my own in the backburner. I’ve realized I guess the hard way of having jobs that last less for a year to only be unemployed for roughly the same time; only to have that cycle repeat itself basically means driving over a cliff.

GregLocock:

I’ve never had a problem with moving, I have realized that I must move rather than waiting for an opportunity to knock at my door. It’s a good thing that I don’t have a family yet as that would have made things that much more difficult.

Moltenmetal:

My mom definitely took life by the horns and can take care of herself that’s for sure. I should have done the transition a year or two ago like you said. And the most important thing is to not allow my skills to go stale and basically loose the education that I have received all those previous years!

Ivymike:

I have to agree that while I do not mind moving anywhere nationally, except maybe for Alaska, I think internationally would be quite far. Although I’ve never really sat down and thought about it since a job hasn’t presented itself, I’m not sure how common or uncommon it is for companies to send off engineers to work internationally whether permanently or in cycles.

Thanks again.
 
“What will think my wall about my shadow?

I ask me sometimes until seeing me questioning me things

Then I dislike me, and I bother me

As if because of this I felt a dormant foot”

(A.Caeiro) Fernando Pessoa - Portugal


Fight Marquez don´t give up!
 
Three of my five engineering jobs have come from the newspaper classifieds. And yet, I think the classifieds are pretty low in terms of looking for technical positions.

I don't agree with moving before finding a job. That's VERY expensive and there are lots of companys that pay for that. I sent out over 300 solicited resumes during the 18 months after I graduated. I think that's the ticket, solicited resumes. Don't waste your time sending a cold resume to a company that isn't even looking, most likely it joins the junk mail recycle bin.

I wouldn't go back to school either for the same reason. The last two jobs paid for additional schooling. I'm currently earning my MS full paid by my employer. I'm in classes with a number of coworkers getting their PhD. I can't believe how hard I worked for grants and scholarships when I was getting my BS but once I get a job, I get a free ride.

I'm assuming you've taken advantage of the locate state employment commission. They usually have free seminars, training, resume services, internet (very important!), etc. They were very helpful when I was laid off. I'm assuming you already regularly visit the obvious oil&gas company websites, power, big electronics players, semiconductor, aircraft manufacturers, defense, AND (most important) US Office of Personnel Management (subcontracted now days).

I keep my eye on the market and am somewhat frustrated at the high number of entry-level positions available. Seems most companies are cutting costs any way they can.

It's hard not to be discouraged but hang in there! Play up your bilingual skills and don't worry about the writing. It'll come if necessary. Teaching is also very rewarding and you should be in demand since technical academics are weak in most schools. You'll have to deal with state certifications, though, and that may require up to two more years of schooling. I inquired about this when I graduated and my school/state provided me with a list of additional classes I'd need including (can you believe it!) remedial and general math courses. They said my math background was too specialized. Who comes up with these requirements, philosophy and history majors?

You are having a tough time and it's very discouraging, I know. But keep at it and you'll soon be flying all over the country for interview. Just make sure you have a credit card for use only when you do travel for interviews. I ran into a problem with that when I was laid off and looking for work. The hoops I had to jump through to work with the interviewing company for flight, car rental, hotel, etc. I am sure cost me the job. But it was a cool experience and they put me up in a hotel I would never have been able to afford.

Hang in there and someday, you'll look back from a great job and remember when times seemed hopeless.
 
the reason people suggest "unsolicited" resumes is that there is a belief that most jobs are not advertised so basically you're talking a chance hoping that something might come through. somehow i don't believe in unsolicited resumes either.

btw, i'm in a similar position as the original poster. i think moving is the key with or without a job. there's just too much entry level competition out there to expect a company to fly you in for an interview when they have hundreds of locals to choose from.
 
I only have my experience to pull from and that does not establish a trend. The large electronics company I worked for in the '80s (not an engineer) brought in boatloads of graduate engineers over a 3 year period. A large construction company hired me in '01 as an experienced engineer but brought in a large number (over 200) graduate engineers from all disciplines not including drafters. It was a large project with 1200 total engineers on staff. My current company has regular job postings for entry level engineers. All of these examples pulled their hires from all over the US and paid for the moves.

The company I mentioned in the above post where I lost out on the position was hiring mostly entry-level. I thought it was a done deal because the phone interview was brief and they flew my wife and myself out for the face to face and hooked us up with a realtor. Good thing the job didn't go through, this was in 1997 and was a $4B semiconductor startup. We know what happened, don't we.

Just goes to show, sometimes the discouraging outcomes turn out the be the best overall. I'm not saying moving without a job should never be done, I did it. However, it was not the brightest thing I've done and I was trying to meet other goals beyond career (lifestyle change). I still think you can get a entrylevel position with a company that will move you. Just gotta be in the right place at the right time. Keep your networking up and resumes out, the odds are you'll get hits soon enough. Contractors for government work are good ones to move you. Try Department of Energy contractors.
 
that must be a really long time ago. wish it was that easy.
 
My first job was from sending an unsolicited resume (or CV as they're usually called in the UK).

I'd especially suggest this technique for smaller companies that may not have the same resources for recruitment.

For larger companies unless you really target the cover letter to someone or a specific department you're sure you'd be a fit for it may not be worth the effort. Many larger companies have a website you can register on though.

Slightly different but when I moved to the states I had to spend a year working retail before I finally got a job in engineering, although I did have experience. Hope that encourages you a little.
 
During the course of your entire work career you'll see 5 or 6 cycles of employment. The secret is to be employed during a downturn and looking during an upturn. Kind of like "buy low, sell high", easier said than done.

I always keep one eye on the job market even though I'm perfectly happy with the position I'm in. My last two job changes occurred because I saw new opportunities when I didn't need to. They yielded 40% and 26% pay increase respectively. I'm very fortunate to have few "must find work" moments so I sympathize, DONMARQUEZ. It's tough and discouraging but keep at it, it will pay off. I wish I had your bilingual skills, I think that's a big plus.

I too had to work at Wally World (aka, Walmart) while looking for work. I found that I couldn't devote enough time to job hunting to make an effective effort so I ended up quiting. That's when the credit cards maxed out and the creditors started burning crosses in my front yard.

By the way, I've always wondered what CV meant with reference to resumes.
 
CV stands for curriculum vitae.

CV is also in common use here in the States for academic positions.

 
Ok, so don't move just yet. Have you made internet applications to all the chemical companies and EPC firms that deal in chemical plants? You might be suprised....

-The future's so bright I gotta wear shades!
 
0707:

Yeah I don’t plan on giving up, or at least not in the nearby future!

Quantum50:

I have to agree that having a major source of finding jobs mainly by the newspaper and the internet are usually the least successful ways of landing a job without the traditional avenues of networking. I used to do unsolicited resumes and found that to be rather ineffective. It is sort of like doing the “throw as much as you can against the window and see what sticks” routine. I have always heard that a good percentage of jobs are usually not advertised out there to the mass public, and this was the reason I tried that route but not having anyone bite the bait. I think it is almost unanimous when it comes to obtaining a higher degree. Most folks will say to wait until you are employed by a company that will pay a part of the cost. It’s sort of killing two birds with one stone in a sense. You don’t get a free ride but you get a nice discount, and considering that usually the available degrees that the company will pay for will benefit them as well, although that may not always be the case. I agree that moving in my current situation is a really big risk and eventually if I do move it will incur a big expense. I have tried the local county commission, but they were barely any help at all. I know that some states are rather industrialized, but not here in Miami. Most job posting were for minimum wage non-technical jobs. Aside from looking at my resume and giving me a few websites that I already knew about, there was not much help that I could get out of them. I do keep an eye on the big name companies out there from time to time to see if positions are available.

I will have to share the same degree of frustration as you when you notice the amount of entry level positions available. I remember a few months ago a company had a small window of opportunity for two Process Engineer I positions for recent graduates. I laughed when I read the requirements; they were in the lines of knowing Microsoft Word etc. I am pretty sure they were trying to get the message across that they were willing to teach the new candidates from scratch, but they should have put in fine print that those jobs were reserved to folks in the North East of people who graduated from one of the top schools. I applied of course with no reply. I have read upon becoming a teacher that it may take two more years of schooling, I think two years from now that would basically take me off the field of ever becoming an engineer. By the way, I am trying to focus more on government positions because at least they do seem more stable. My experiences with small and medium private sized companies have been horrendous, and news about the billion dollar companies laying-off thousands if not tens of thousands of workers in the years to come is nothing new. I’ll keep at it for the months to come, but I am also starting to plan on having a safety net just in case. I do take the word “contractor” as a double edged sword though. It seems that even though there are positions out there with a pretty good start up pay and wonderful experience to gain, it always seems that they want someone who doesn’t need to be assembled from scratch or rather still wet behind the ears without any real world experience.

anu2004:

Yeah my thoughts exactly, trying to throw as much as you can to see if one will stick to the window is very time consuming and the least beneficial method of trying to land a job. I also had that belief that most jobs were not advertised and that was the reason I was doing it.

Kenat:

Thanks for your valuable comment and I do have a rather interesting question for you. You said that you worked retail for about a year before landing your job here in the states. I was wondering, did the companies you interviewed you saw this year as a “blotch” in your resume and/or did they question you what you were doing for that year when you were working in the retailing business, and if so what was your answer?

Sms:

Thanks for your response as well, I know you meant well with the moving idea. I don’t think that it is possible for right now, but hopefully in the near future if I see a window of opportunity, I will take it. By the way when you mean EPC, do you mean companies that deal with construction and engineering projects such as power plants, process plants, and oil rigs? I have applied to a few of these but rather seldom. I rarely see these types of jobs posted. However if you do know of a website that has these job openings or a website with resources that deals with this subject, I would be most grateful if you could show me the light.
 
I actually ended up getting my job out of the blue through an agency I'd applied to for a couple of other jobs months earlier. Although I think they just got my resume from an online site not their own! They basically told me to keep it quiet as I recall.

That said I think it came up in a couple of interviews. General perception seemed to be 'you gotta do what you gotta do' but of course I only got one of those jobs. My situation was of course slightly different. Also during my time in retail I managed to get up to the heady heights of shift supervisor which again might have looked a bit better than just cashier.

Personally at your stage in your career if I was hiring I'd probably rather see some non relevant work on a resume rather than a gap of presumably unemployment but that may not be how others perceive it. To me working a job shows a good work ethic etc and that you'll make the extra effort but I've had very limited involvement in the recruiting process so don't take my word on it.

You can hide it to some extent by making your resume more functional than chronological but it will probably come up eventually.
 
Forgot to say, because of my immigration situation I wasn't eligable for unemployment so pretty much had to take whatever came along.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor