Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by mrsutton

  1. mrsutton

    Canadian seismic vertical force?

    Looking through the NBCC I'm not seeing anything related to applying or accounting for any vertical acceleration due to seismic ground motion: just horizontal forces only. Am I missing something or is the 0.9DL combo considered to address that?
  2. mrsutton

    Canadian seismic design requirements

    To any engineers familiar with the NBCC's seismic design: are there any provisions for including some portion of snow or ice loads as part of a structure's seismic mass? I looked through the NBCC and Alberta provincial codes and didn't see anything regarding this but I could be missing...
  3. mrsutton

    Canadian ice and wind-on-ice procedure

    Thanks. I've been trying to track down a free copy of the CSA S37 document with no luck as all the pdfs of that code I've found via Google search are behind paywalls. All the articles I've found Googling Canadian ice loads have been academic research papers relating to marine ice floes impeding...
  4. mrsutton

    Canadian ice and wind-on-ice procedure

    How does the Canadian NBC or engineering practice address the weight of glaze ice on structural components for vertical, wind, and seismic? The NBCC and Alberta Code I've got access to don't seem to even mention ice loading at all--which I find surprising given how much of Canada is so far...
  5. mrsutton

    Correct application of Omega for equipment anchorage to concrete per ASCE7-10 Chapter 13

    Just to respond to everybody... I asked SK Ghosh for guidance on the application of Omega for equipment anchorage. He basically said we should apply it per the letter of the code and that it was really ACI's, not ASCE's, call. So it appears we'll be reverting our spreadsheet back to the...
  6. mrsutton

    A325 N and A325 X

    You would in generally always want threading Xcluded from the shear plane since that is an area of bolt with smaller net cross section--however in many cases the bolts are overdesigned and it doesn't matter (so Ncluded is OK). It all depends on your calcs.
  7. mrsutton

    yield stress for hilti anchor bolts

    Check the ICC report for anchor rod steel Fy and Fu. Those values should all be listed there. Those values are usually not of interest to engineers designing an anchorage because the concrete bond and concrete itself will typically fail long before the steel rods do.
  8. mrsutton

    self tapping screws to HSS

    I believe some of the new Simpson screws for attaching their new line of light gauge clips to structural steel will drive through 1/4" material. Teks is certainly the most commonly specified hardware though.
  9. mrsutton

    ASCE 7-10 Chapter 15 Seismic Loading on Tanks

    There are two tank design methodologies that ASCE7 Chapter 15 refers back to: API-650 (mostly used for welded steel tanks found in tank farms) AWWA D100 (water tanks of any material and occasionally elevated up on stands) I've only anchored tanks per AWWA D100 but if you can get your hands on...
  10. mrsutton

    Chopra Example for El Centro

    Back in structural dynamics we did a team project doing time history from El Centro for a 10-story steel building in ETABS. I think the El Centro record could be uploaded into it from some other site. It's been too long to remember now--but I'm sure if you Googled "El Centro time history record...
  11. mrsutton

    Wind Pressure Minimum requirements

    The min is 9.6(typically rounded up 10)PSF ASD and 16PSF ULT.
  12. mrsutton

    Torsion in I beams

    You should check AISC H3 (13th ed...not sure about 14th) for design checks. If you want to go real deep into it the torsion will add additional shear stresses at the extremities of the beam's cross-section. AISC has a design manual with lots of fun charts developed from diff. equations for...
  13. mrsutton

    concrete slab on grade point loading: Enercalc vs. Ringo & Anderson

    I found at least a summary of the primary academic paper referenced in both Structure magazine and Enercalc help. The best I could tell was the formula was developed based on a best-fit regression of a bunch of FEA model slabs on grade loaded to failure--not real slabs. I'm sure Ringo being...
  14. mrsutton

    special wind regions, local code posting

    It might be addressed at the county level but we all figured it was done by local municipality building department--especially since some counties out west can be the size of states back east. San Bernardino County is just a little smaller than West Virginia for example. But I agree the local...
  15. mrsutton

    special wind regions, local code posting

    We tried a half-dozen neighboring towns with no success. The biggest town nearby, Palm Springs, listed "122.5Vult" on their site somewhere (someone else in the office found the page) but I'm not even sure if that means 122.5mph RCII Vult or 122.5% of whatever the IBC mapped value nearby would be.

Part and Inventory Search