It might seem obvious but hasn't yet been stated--I think this this entire discussion hinges on if the column/anchorage is being designed as a truly embedded column (as per the latest edition of AISC Design Guide 1 for example) versus a normal column that just happens to be bearing below slab...
i dont disagree entirely with this mindset, but also for structures that are well-defined and that I perceive as having a low risk of future changes/modifications I have no issue designing repetitive elements with a utilization ratio approaching 1.0. that said, its not crazy to me to imagine a...
OK, for one, please stop deleting and reposting your thread because you don't like my reply.
For two, original reply:
LPile is designed for the complex case of columns being embedded into various stratum of variable stiffness that are loaded laterally. Very difficult to do with hand...
Hi all,
We frequently design large industrial buildings with steel deck diaphragms. Some of our customers desire to install multiple, very large roof vents to properly ventilate certain production areas. I have been trying to better understand exactly how to properly design the diaphragm for...
this is a fascinating thread, best one in months! Looking forward to KootK's response to Larry's above. Appreciate everyone on this forum and the shared knowledge.
Just played with Risa3D + RisaFloor for the afternoon and I hate it. The back and forth between them is unintuitive and just outright sucks. Better yet, after finally getting a model setup correct I found this in the help docs...
I don't mind the software not being able to design the diaphragm itself, I just want the behavior accurately captured on the analysis side. With metal deck diaphragms like I'm mostly referring to, their design is frequently dictated by manufacturer's specifications anyways and so that part of...
Hi all, my team is looking for a software that has the following (apparently hard to find) qualities:
[ol 1]
The ability to capture flexible diaphragm behavior correctly. I say "correctly" simply because the software I've demo'd so far that claims to have this feature does not dump the diaphragm...
60% of the beam spacing for me. Theres a reference somewhere around here for that percentage, cant find it currently though.
This usually works out to be about the same width as a 30 deg angle each way with the point load between the 2 beams.
Usually I allow the use of short slots in collectors personally. IMO, it depends on the building construction, but for warehouse style construction (steel superstructure, metal deck diaphragm, metal cladding, etc), these structures are quite flexible-- any movement from bolt slip will not cause...
If you specify for the decking to be fastened directly to the beam, and that deck to beam connection is sufficient to transfer your diaphragm shear, then the edge angle is rendered non-structural at least from a lateral force resisting element perspective.
I would be more comfortable with a detail similar to below:
I have seen this detail used successfully in the past and I believe addresses some of your concerns.
You may want to look into having the top chord reinf be discontinuous at panel points to avoid fouling the web member connections...
Just jumping in here to expand a little on DayRooster's post-- keep in mind that while steel decking use back be dated back to the 30s, it wasn't used as a diaphragm until the mid 60s.
Between the 30s and 60s steel decking was just a vertical load transferring element to span between secondary...
its probably been said already in this thread, but your website design and graphic design skills are off the charts! Tribby looks great, hope to offer some constructive feedback.
Therein lies the issue for me. Personally I love the "doing" of structural engineering. I do not have an appetite for project management or sales. But I feel as though I will never have the opportunity to make the 'big bucks' without going down that path.
If only technical knowledge translated...
Not sure that you will be able to find any publications that will have dealt directly with this issue, however short of enlisting a vibration specialist to do some FEA you can be proactive and use good practice methods to reduce vibrations. Things like specifying minimum Ix requirements for the...
JAE, thank you for the responses. I will give both of your suggestions a try in excel. I can set up the equations and try all values between 8-32 in the denominator to see if they converge to a solution. I can do the same thing with your other suggestion by solving some beam formulas.
To your...
I have attached my calculation for the solid (no openings) panel that aligns well with the software output.
Anyone have any ideas on how openings that create a varying stiffness panel would affect these calcs, considering moment of inertia is required to solve for restraining force?
EDIT:
had...