Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Loads/Units shown on drawings 2

EngDM

Structural
Aug 10, 2021
591
How particular are you guys with the proper capitalization of units on drawings? Personally I prefer that everything is shown with the correct letter case, especially when it comes to the units that are named after someone I.E. Newtons or Pascals, but often time I am reviewing drawings and everything is uppercase. So you get stuff in the general notes for a distance such as MM for millimeters, or KN/M.

I know it is unlikely that any errors are actually made from this, since the units are so standardized, but in a case where MPa is shown as mPa, it technically makes a massive difference.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

And then an unfortunate percentage will use this "ambiguity" as an opportunity to "think it was something else" and then charge the owner an extra and blame you for it.
That's never happened on one of my projects in nearly 38 years of practice. I had one plan checker (DSA in CA) insist and I did so to get the plans approved. I had another plan checker at a local municipality. He dropped it after I pushed back.
Just how can this be misinterpreted?
 
Just because it requires experience, doesn't mean some of these cowboy contractors are going to have it. The last thing I need is different ways to interpret my drawings due to omission of abbreviations.
I'm sorry that I haven't been making myself clear. Which sort of highlights my point.

Interpretation is everything and not matter how meticulous you are you can't rule out other people mis-interpreting drawings. There are ALWAYS different ways to interpret drawings.

You have some interpreted my comments as making the assumption that I'm against clarity, abbreviations or legends in drawings. Far from it. But none of that removes the requirement that those reading have the skills and knowledge to interpret them. As I've said repeatedly in the example previously, 2x10 means is completely open to interpretation.
 
@EngDM, I mentioned in an earlier comment, but newtons and pascals (as units) are always spelt in lower case
Yea I saw that and I appreciate the correction so I can use this going forward. Thing is, I haven't used either of those words since then? Are you confusing the new way the forum shows the original post always at the top, regardless of what comment page you are on, with new comments?

I can no longer edit that post just an FYI.

post.png
 

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor