peebee
Electrical
- Jun 10, 2002
- 1,209
On an existing generator-utility full-time paralleling installation, there is an ANSI 21 Distance Relay monitoring the incoming utility MV feeder. This was specified to be provided for this customer-owned installation by the utility as a condition of operation of the system.
Per the Red Book, a 21 distance relay "is a relay that functions when the circuit admittance, impedance, or reactance increases or decreases beyond a predetermined value".
Where does the word "distance" come in to play here? nothing in the above description mentions distance.
What is the point of this relay -- what does it do that a 27 undervoltage, 50/51/G overcurrent, or 59G overvoltage (ground-fault) relay wouldn't pick up? As a practical matter, every single time that the 21 has tripped, the 59G has also tripped. Are the 21 and 59G more-or-less redundant to each other, or is the 21 truely providing some additional level of protection? Is the 21 more accurate, or maybe faster?
How do these things actually work? Are they really monitoring source system impedance as the description seems to imply? Or perhaps, the transmission line impedance? How do they do that?
Per the Red Book, a 21 distance relay "is a relay that functions when the circuit admittance, impedance, or reactance increases or decreases beyond a predetermined value".
Where does the word "distance" come in to play here? nothing in the above description mentions distance.
What is the point of this relay -- what does it do that a 27 undervoltage, 50/51/G overcurrent, or 59G overvoltage (ground-fault) relay wouldn't pick up? As a practical matter, every single time that the 21 has tripped, the 59G has also tripped. Are the 21 and 59G more-or-less redundant to each other, or is the 21 truely providing some additional level of protection? Is the 21 more accurate, or maybe faster?
How do these things actually work? Are they really monitoring source system impedance as the description seems to imply? Or perhaps, the transmission line impedance? How do they do that?