Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet
Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals
What are the differences between Specification,Code and Standard?
- Thread starter pipeng90
- Start date
LittleInch
Petroleum
Specification - Defines the technical requirements of a piece of equipment, often requiring adherence to a particular national or international standard. Often custom written for a particular purpose it allows the customer to specify particular additions, changes or deletions to any specified standard for his particular use.
Code - Often termed design code, this is a document which defines the method of designing a particular piece of plant or equipment, e.g. B 31.4 is a design code, which specifies how you design a liquid pipeline under all sorts of different conditions
This is an extract from the introduction which xplains it better:
The Code sets forth engineering requirements deemed necessary for safe design and construction
of pressure piping. While safety is the basic consideration, this factor alone will not necessarily
govern the final specifications for any piping system. The designer is cautioned that the Code
is not a design handbook; it does not do away with the need for the designer or for competent
engineering judgment.
To the greatest possible extent, Code requirements for design are stated in terms of basic design
principles and formulas. These are supplemented as necessary with specific requirements to
ensure uniform application of principles and to guide selection and application of piping elements.
The Code prohibits designs and practices known to be unsafe and contains warnings where
caution, but not prohibition, is warranted.
A Standard is a national or international document which sets out how a particular item is to be designed, fabricated and tested so that it meets certain minimum requirements for safety and operation and allows "standardisation" of certain items to prevent multiple version being used. An example would be ASME B 16.5 - Pipe flanges
I hope this isn't homework....
Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.
Code - Often termed design code, this is a document which defines the method of designing a particular piece of plant or equipment, e.g. B 31.4 is a design code, which specifies how you design a liquid pipeline under all sorts of different conditions
This is an extract from the introduction which xplains it better:
The Code sets forth engineering requirements deemed necessary for safe design and construction
of pressure piping. While safety is the basic consideration, this factor alone will not necessarily
govern the final specifications for any piping system. The designer is cautioned that the Code
is not a design handbook; it does not do away with the need for the designer or for competent
engineering judgment.
To the greatest possible extent, Code requirements for design are stated in terms of basic design
principles and formulas. These are supplemented as necessary with specific requirements to
ensure uniform application of principles and to guide selection and application of piping elements.
The Code prohibits designs and practices known to be unsafe and contains warnings where
caution, but not prohibition, is warranted.
A Standard is a national or international document which sets out how a particular item is to be designed, fabricated and tested so that it meets certain minimum requirements for safety and operation and allows "standardisation" of certain items to prevent multiple version being used. An example would be ASME B 16.5 - Pipe flanges
I hope this isn't homework....
Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.
- Thread starter
- #3
Therefore, regarding to mentioned explanation, "specification" prefers to "standard" and "code". Isn't it?
And, what is difference between this "specification"(mentioned definition) with, e.g. SA-106 (Specification for C.S. pipe)? I think SA-106 (or A-106) is a standard but read in its scope as a Specification. However, is SA-106 a standard or not?
And, what is difference between this "specification"(mentioned definition) with, e.g. SA-106 (Specification for C.S. pipe)? I think SA-106 (or A-106) is a standard but read in its scope as a Specification. However, is SA-106 a standard or not?
EdStainless
Materials
SA-106 is part of a Code, a legally binding set of requirements governing the design, materials, and fabrication of pressure equipment.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
P.E. Metallurgy, Plymouth Tube
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
P.E. Metallurgy, Plymouth Tube
LittleInch
Petroleum
The official title as from the asme site is that something like A 105 is a "Standard Specification".
There is some confusion within the industry and peoples usage, but the "definitions" above will act as a good guide.
The view is that a "specification" could be a specific document OR a standard material such as "make it from A105 spec materials"
Code is much more design and can be used in a legal fashion. A code often references a number of Standards specifications which it relies on (see the section titled normative references).
It is a bit confusing I agree but hope this gets the main issues over to you.
Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.
There is some confusion within the industry and peoples usage, but the "definitions" above will act as a good guide.
The view is that a "specification" could be a specific document OR a standard material such as "make it from A105 spec materials"
Code is much more design and can be used in a legal fashion. A code often references a number of Standards specifications which it relies on (see the section titled normative references).
It is a bit confusing I agree but hope this gets the main issues over to you.
Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question
- Locked
- Question