same mesh different results

[mirb3000]

I guys I ran the analysis, one in ansys 15 and the other in natran 12
My surprise is that the location and the numbers are very different.
Anyone can help me to understand this results
Thanks in advance!

 

[assafwei]

From the picture you attached it seems that the deflection of the two cases is different.
Are you sure you used the same BCs for both?

 

[mirb3000]

Hi
Yes all is the same.
Please see this new attachment