Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Stupid Truck Driver

Status
Not open for further replies.

bridgebuster

Active member
Jun 27, 1999
3,964

Dump truck taking out an overhead sign structure.

Link
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

A dump truck took down a pedestrian overpass in my city just a couple of weeks ago in the exact same way!

I've never driven in a dump truck, but wouldn't there be alarms to alert the driver that their bucket it up?
 
LOL
Love the shocked comments.

I wish the video was rationally wide instead of moronically narrow.

Sad no one was able to signal the driver. It looks like, fortunately, all the other vehicles were spaced just right to prevent any fatalities.

Keith Cress
kcress -
 
This subject has been discussed in earlier threads...

thread507-369112

--
JHG
 
Check out 11foot8.com If you find trucks running into bridges interesting. Some guy has a bunch of video cameras rolling 24/7 on the same bridge in Durham, NC. Great commentary. His youTube channel has at least 100 different videos of trucks hitting the same poor bridge.


I can't believe it is still standing.
 
jg2828 - 11foot8 They don't hit the bridge - the railroad put a beam across, a little shorter than the bridge so that anything that fits beneath the beam clears the bridge. They now have a height sensor and a huge sign and still drivers fail to understand the height of the vehicle they are in.
 
11foot8, yup, lots of car-nage, or I guess, truck-nage ;-)

Seems to me that the cost of just cleaning up the debris for each collision with the bar would pay for a sensor that measures the height of the oncoming truck and force the light to stay red until the truck turns off to one of the side streets.

TTFN (ta ta for now)
I can do absolutely anything. I'm an expert! faq731-376 forum1529 Entire Forum list
 
IRstuff - If it stayed red, how would anyone ahead of the truck get through/how would it trigger in time to stop a truck if it's measured just as the truck gets to the light?

The current height sensor setup triggers a sign with "TOO TALL, TURN NOW" or the like, but people still think it doesn't apply to their vehicle. Maybe they need to add a counter with the number of hits the protection beam has taken. "HIT 145 TIMES."

At least it's not like the other, nastier buddy, 11Foot8's Evil Little Brother (10Foot6) that includes the collide-o-matic sidewalk: It's known for the famous lobster-truck fire.
 
I believe that the famous 11-foot-8 underpass *has* installed such red lights, but the carnage continues.

Wasn't it in Sydney Australia where they had to install a system to dump a wall of water in front of the trucks to make them stop?

Let me find a picture... yes, with a giant projected STOP sign. I'll bet that they still have the occasional incident.

URL]
 
Never be amazed or surprised by a driver's ability to hit something with his vehicle. When I was still operating wreckers I saw all manner of bridges and signs get hit, and also one car that fell off a transporter.
 
Thanks for the link 3DDave. I hadn't seen the 10 foot 6 bridge video. That one seems to do a lot more damage, completely ripping the boxes off the trucks instead of just peeling them open.
 
Yes but why? Is it because if you simply dropped a screen or curtain it would be harder to reset? Bearing in mind that presumably some wagon is going to have to spend some time backing up anyway.
I'm guessing that there is a sound case for using that technology but I wonder what the reasoning is.
A screen wouldn't need a projector (unless the driver wasn't using his lights) and how visible is a projection onto a curtain of water when the sun is shining brightly?
I will concede that it's very cool though!

"I love deadlines. I love the whooshing noise they make as they go past." Douglas Adams
 
As a kid, I thought the Army's bazooka was the world's coolest weapon.
Now, rig one with a trigger hooked to a "you are still too tall" sensor behind the overhead beam .... 8<)

A Star Wars horizontal light sabre would work too.
 
"Now, rig one with a trigger"

Not going to save much money or time that way; there'll still be debris on the roadway.

Might be better to make use of the curvy curb in the 10ft6 bridge, which seems to be really good at diverting vehicles, so the trigger shifts the curb and force the truck into a right turn.

TTFN (ta ta for now)
I can do absolutely anything. I'm an expert! faq731-376 forum1529 Entire Forum list
 
RobWard, my guess is this:

Stopping sight distance for a passenger car is ~500 feet (150m) at 55 mph (80 km/h). A loaded truck needs more than that, so let's assume the screen is triggered when the truck is 700 feet (200m) from the tunnel portal. At 2.5 second headways, there could be three vehicles between the portal and the overheight truck. Probably ten vehicles if they drive like NY City drivers.*

So, several of those vehicles are going to be closer than stopping sight distance to the portal when the system is activated. They can go through the water curtain without damaging anything except perhaps their undershorts. A physical screen would be damaged when the car collided with it.

I was wondering how well it shows up in daylight, too, especially when the sun is low on an east-west roadway.

*I was told the NYC standard is, if you can see the back tires of the vehicle in front of you, you're not tailgating.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor