Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. manstrom

    Request for proposal, remodel all non load bearing wall

    I'd create a task to "review existing drawings and identify bearing walls, if any. Write a report". If additional structural design is required, we can perform that work as hourly / TBD. Don't discount your ability to review drawings and ID structural elements.
  2. manstrom

    ACI 319-19 One way shear provisions for walls and slabs

    I'm not sure this issue has sunk in yet at the real world level. I'm just getting into projects using IBC 21 / ACI 318-19. I believe (and hope) the intention was to have an exception for walls, footings, one way slabs since they can't really accommodate stirrups. As Jed said, how do I explain...
  3. manstrom

    ACI 319-19 One way shear provisions for walls and slabs

    Thanks I found that thread previously. It addressed beams, but I'm more concerned about slabs, walls, footings. I also appreciate your quote there:
  4. manstrom

    ACI 319-19 One way shear provisions for walls and slabs

    There have been a few posts on this, but I don't think this has been properly addressed by the ACI. In the ACI 318-19, there is a new table for calculating one way shear. Table 22.5.5.1 shows three formulas. Formula (a) and (b) simplify to the familiar equation phi*2*sqrt(f'c)*b*d times...
  5. manstrom

    Relative deflection in wood roof trusses

    A good reason to: -Put a max deflection limit on trusses -Realize that L/240 over 60' is pretty damn big -Not do 60' trusses that thin. A good truss designer would have flagged this and brought it up to the SER. A good SER would have noticed this during shop review. IMO, a 2.75"...
  6. manstrom

    FTAO straps

    I allow on the inside. Then I can see that they actually installed them. If it's outside, then it's under tyvek and I can't see anything. In a perfect world, outside (on sheathing) is better. I'd should look up the APA paper.
  7. manstrom

    Lag screws for residential projects

    I stopped using them a long time ago.
  8. manstrom

    New Opening in Existing Slab

    I'd just GPR the slab and avoid cutting rebar. Save yourself a week of engineering time. 6x5" holes are not that much in a 12'x14'slab (I had to convert to freedom units) To answer your question, I would distribute as much as you can justify by the amount of rebar in the slab. If that were a...
  9. manstrom

    Wood Tie Retaining Wall

    In my experience, that wall may last 20-25 years tops
  10. manstrom

    Any way to design a 9 m (30 ft) high cantilever masonry fire wall?

    I would say no. Not really possible without counterforts or big piers. In cases like this, the wall is usually tied to both buildings with ties that would melt away in a fire.
  11. manstrom

    CMU beam bearings fracturing

    Allowable bearing stress for masonry is pretty garbage. I think it is 1/3 f'm (or it used to be). 500 psi is less than a Southern Pine plate. Also, the stress may be delivered more as a triangle / trapezoid than a uniform rectangular pressure. On top of that, you will have some thermal...
  12. manstrom

    What custom spreadsheet are you most proud of?

    I spent a lot of time and effort on a 5 story rigid diaphragm analysis spreadsheet for wood construction.
  13. manstrom

    Hydrostatic Uplift Vs Column Gravity Loads

    Can you add concrete mass to create higher DL?
  14. manstrom

    Long Span Wood Truss Roof/ Overall Stability

    Wood truss? 70' is a tough one to put on a truck. How is the sheathing going to span 7'? I'd worry about truss bracing too. What will be required for the uplift and probably diagonals. Wind loads from the walls will go from the bottom chord up to the top chord, then diaphragm. This is...
  15. manstrom

    Designing a brick veneer single angle

    For a 4" leg angle or so, yes. There are published charts and standards for this. The brick is tight to the angle and the brick ties brace rotation. Now, if you try to design 4" brick on a 5" or 6" angle (because of the airspace), that's where it gets a little wonky. Angles are terrible in...
  16. manstrom

    Floor Sheathing Span Rating Tables

    APA should have stuff apawood.org
  17. manstrom

    Beam/Joist/Framing Software Latest and Greatest Choices

    I use Forte and Enercalc. I have used Beamchek with success. I've used Woodworks, but it didn't do anything that Forte couldn't do I also use and write a lot of excel spreadsheets for shear walls and random things. The online AWC web app for connection design. It is hard to beat.
  18. manstrom

    Font size on drawing

    In (hand) drafting class, we were taught minimum text is 1/8". When I got to the real world, we let 3/32" work. It fit better between lines at 1/8" apart (12" on 1/8" scale). Nothing smaller ever. Most plans are half size now so a 1/16" font won't show up.
  19. manstrom

    Lintel required to hold brick wall.

    That's some goofy architect crap. Just because they can draw it doesn't mean it can be built (easily). Forget doing this out of masonry, the detailing and craftsmanship will be a pain. As masonry, it would need a ton of reinforcing at weird angles. I can't imagine how I would detail that...

Part and Inventory Search